How to Show Up in Local Search Results: Local SEO for Small Businesses
Small Business SEO, AI SEO, SEO for Beginners, Simple SEO Podcast
Today I want to walk you through exactly how to show up in local search results if you're a small business that serves a local area, a brick-and-mortar shop, or a service-based business working in person. If you're online-only, this particular post isn't going to be as useful, but you may still learn a few things that will help your overall SEO or AI SEO plans.
How to show up in local search results
Whether we're talking about SEO or AI SEO, Google or AI-based search, the goal is the same: make it easy for people in your area to find your business, and make sure AI search knows who you are, where you're located, and who you help. Here's exactly how to do this for your website, step by step.
Use the city and area names your customers actually use
When you're choosing keywords and writing the copy on your website, you want to include the specific cities you serve in both your copy and in your optimization elements.
I live in Tucson, Arizona. I have a page on my site for my local SEO consulting work, optimized for "Tucson SEO consultant." On that page, I don't just talk about Tucson. I also mention several surrounding areas a local business owner would recognize: Oro Valley, Marana, Sahuarita, Vail.
Here's why that matters. If I'd only optimized for Oro Valley, or only for Marana, or only for Sahuarita, I'd be limiting my reach significantly. Those smaller towns might have 50,000 to 100,000 people each. By including all of them alongside Tucson, I'm reaching the whole Tucson metro area, which is closer to a million people, while staying within that same core service area.
Adding the location information is really important for local SEO, but you also want to make sure you’re thinking about how your customer refers to their local area. In some areas, listing the cities makes sense, and in other areas it really doesn’t.
Many years ago, I was the marketing manager for a children's franchise company, working with franchise owners in 175 locations across the country, and local store marketing was a big part of what I taught them.
Some of you will be in areas where it makes sense to use the city name directly, the way I do with Tucson. Others are in bigger, more spread-out metro areas where that won't work as well.
Phoenix is a good example. It's one of the largest cities in the country, and it can take over an hour to drive end to end, so optimizing for just "Phoenix" may not be ideal depending on where in the metro area your business is located.
In Phoenix, some people are in Phoenix proper, others are in Scottsdale, or East Valley or West Valley, and because of that, you want to make sure you're optimizing for the correct areas of the valley.
The East Valley might mean cities like Mesa, Tempe, Chandler, and Ahwatukee, while West Valley might mean Goodyear, Peoria, and Glendale. A realtor selling homes in Chandler, Gilbert, Ahwatukee, and Queen Creek almost certainly isn't also showing homes in Glendale, Peoria, Surprise, or Verrado. They're too far apart.
As a local business, it’s important to think about this when deciding which towns or locations to include on your website.
Some areas even have their own regional shorthand. I learned years ago that Delaware, Maryland, and Virginia together get referred to as Delmarva. If that's your area, that's the term to use: "I help families with window treatments in Delmarva."
Whatever term or city your own customers actually use for their region, that's the one that belongs on your website, in your copy, your title tags, and your meta description, so it shows up when someone searches for exactly that in Google or AI Search.
Give that service area its own page so you show up for it
You may want a dedicated page that talks about what you offer in that specific area. I have several students who are bookkeepers. If you're a bookkeeper in Maine, you want a page that talks specifically about being a bookkeeper in Maine, with that local information built right in alongside the service itself. That's what helps Google connect your business to your niche and your location together.
You don’t need to create 5 different pages for bookkeeping in Maine unless you specifically offer five different types of bookkeeping services. You want to make sure you’re providing value and not trying to spam a ton of useless content on your site because neither Google or AI Search likes spammy sites with useless content.
For AI search, consistency matters a lot
Creating the right content, using your location, information in your copy, and optimization elements will help you with both Google and AI Search. For AI search specifically, you want to make sure everything is consistent across all online listings. AI pulls your information from your website, but it also pulls from other places: your Google Business Profile, Yelp, ratings, reviews, and more.
That means your contact information needs to be consistent everywhere. Your local service area should read the same on your website as it does on your Google Business Profile, your Yelp listing, and your Facebook page. Same email address, same phone number, everywhere. That consistency is what helps AI search confidently tie all of that information back to one business, your business.
Your Google Business Profile helps for both Google and AI Search
Your Google Business Profile matters for local SEO, and it matters just as much for AI search. Make sure it has the right keywords and the right location information, so Google and AI search can clearly tie your profile to your business, your area, and what you actually do.
Be sure you verify and fill out your Google Business Profile completely, optimize it by using keywords that your ideal customer would search with, and gather reviews to help boost visibility. You can learn more in this post on how to optimize your Google Business Profile for SEO.
Reviews are important to your SEO and AI SEO
Ratings and reviews are important for SEO, for AI SEO, and honestly, for your ideal customer too. When someone's trying to decide where to spend their money, they're looking at reviews.
Let me tell you a quick story about this.
We're coming up on Christmas, and my husband wanted a specific fancy watch as a gift. Of course, it was sold out directly from the company. So I did what I do: I searched with the model number, tried different keyword combinations, and eventually found it being sold by a small jeweler in Ohio. I'm in Tucson, Arizona, nowhere near Ohio.
I found them through a Google Shopping ad, clicked through, and the site looked legitimate, but I was about to spend a lot of money with a business I'd never heard of, so I went looking for proof. I checked their reviews. I checked their website. I checked what Google and AI could tell me about them. I went through exactly the same research process your ideal customer goes through before buying from you.
They had an option to text with questions, so I did, the same way some of my own students have texted me before enrolling in Simple SEO Content. I ended up talking with their marketing person, confirmed the model number, and made the purchase. Afterward, she asked how I'd even found them, since I was halfway across the country. I walked her through exactly what I'd searched and how I'd landed on their Google Shopping listing. Interestingly, she told me they'd actually removed the model number from their optimization on purpose, because that specific watch was a common target for fraudulent purchases. That gap was part of why I'd reached out to double-check in the first place.
Here's the point: I went from never having heard of this jeweler to buying from them within an hour, because they showed up where I was searching, and because their reviews and reputation gave me enough confidence to trust them with a big purchase. If they hadn't had strong ratings and reviews, both on their own site and on other sites, I probably would have hesitated and kept looking. Make sure your own website has what your ideal customer needs to feel ready to buy, the same way that jeweler did for me.
Start showing up in local search results
If you're not sure where to begin with local SEO and AI SEO for your business, grab the Beginner's Guide to SEO and the Beginner's Guide to AI SEO, both free on my freebies page. There's also the SEO and AI SEO Starter Course, which walks you through setting up your homepage to be found, whether you're a local business or an online one. It’s a self-study class that you can watch in under an hour and make the changes on your site today.
Frequently asked questions about local SEO
Do I need local SEO if I run an online-only business?
No, you don’t need to worry about local SEO if you have an online-only business. Local SEO is specifically for businesses that serve customers in a physical area, brick-and-mortar or in-person service. If you're online-only, you don’t need to do anything for local SEO.
Should I target one neighborhood, or a wider area?
Usually, you will want to target a wider metro area, as long as it's still realistic for you to serve customers within the entire area you’re targeting with your local SEO. Including the surrounding towns or areas around your core city, the way I do with Tucson and its surrounding communities, expands your reach without diluting your relevance. The exception is sprawling metro areas like Phoenix, where you want to narrow to the specific region, like East Valley or West Valley, that your actual customers are in.
Can I do local SEO myself?
Yes, and that's exactly who this post is written for. You don't need to hire an agency to do most of what's here: claiming and filling out your Google Business Profile, keeping your name, address, and phone number consistent everywhere, and asking happy customers for reviews are all things you can do yourself. You can also work on creating the right content for your ideal customer.
Does local SEO still work, now that people search with AI?
Yes, local SEO still works with AI search. In fact, AI search relies heavily on the same signals local SEO has always relied on: your Google Business Profile, your reviews, and consistent information about who you are and where you serve. The difference is that AI search pulls from more places at once, so the local SEO basics aren't optional anymore; they're the foundation AI search is built on too.
What is NAP consistency, and why does it matter for AI search?
NAP stands for name, address, and phone number. AI search pulls your business information from multiple sources- your website, your Google Business Profile, Yelp, and more- so if those details don't match everywhere, it's harder for AI to confidently tie them all back to the same business.
Does my Google Business Profile matter if I already have a website?
Yes. It matters for traditional local SEO and for AI search. Make sure it has accurate keywords and location details, since both Google and AI search use it to understand your business. You want both, not one or the other here.
How many reviews do I actually need?
There's no magic number, but genuine, consistent reviews across your website and other platforms build the trust your ideal customer needs before they buy, and they help both SEO and AI search recognize your business as legitimate and relevant. Focus on building great reviews over time by providing excellent service to the customers you have today.
How do I show up in local search results, step by step?
Start with your Google Business Profile, claimed, verified, and fully filled out. Use the city and area names your customers actually use, not just your own city if your service area is bigger than that. Give your main service area its own page on your site. Keep your name, address, and phone number identical everywhere: your website, Google Business Profile, Yelp, and Facebook. Then build reviews across those same platforms. Do those five things, and you're covering what both Google and AI search are looking for.

